Tank vs Tankless Water Heaters

A tank water heater is cheaper to buy and install. A tankless one costs more up front but never runs out of hot water, lasts about twice as long and takes up less space. Which is right depends on your household and your house.

Illustrative photo of a plumber descaling a tankless water heater

Side by side

CompareGas tank (50 gal)Gas tankless
Typical installed price$1,800 to $3,000$3,500 to $6,500
Lifespan8 to 12 yearsAbout 20 years
Hot water supplyRuns out after a busy hourContinuous, up to its flow rate
SpaceFloor space, about 2 ft acrossWall-hung, suitcase-sized
UpkeepFlush yearly, anode checkDescale yearly, clean inlet filter

When a tank makes more sense

When tankless makes more sense

Plan for the gas line: many tankless units need a larger gas supply than a tank, which is often the hidden cost in a switch.

Hard water and tankless

North Texas water is moderately hard. Scale builds up inside a tankless heat exchanger, so a yearly descale is part of owning one. Isolation valves fitted at install make it a quick job.

Around Frisco

Many newer homes in Frisco, Prosper and Celina were built with tankless units from the start, often in the garage. In older Plano and Carrollton homes, a switch usually means a larger gas line and new venting.

(972) 945-6903